Aamir Khan makes a poignant return with Sitaare Zameen Par, a heartfelt sports-drama that marries emotional depth with social sensitivity. His gentle, flawed coach, Gulshan, transforms through his bond with neurodivergent children—an arc echoing the emotional authenticity of Taare Zameen Par.
The Positives
Aamir and Genelia D’Souza Shine: Netizens praised their tender portrayals, calling the film an “emotional rollercoaster” driven by hope and heart.
Child Cast Steal Scenes: Viewers hailed the special-needs actors as the true stars—“fuller, softer and happier,” wrote Darsheel Safary, former Taare Zameen Par child actor.
Sudha Murty’s Insight: Calling the film an “eye-opener,” she applauded its sensitivity and deep lessons on inclusion.
The Criticisms
Remake Controversy: Critics argue the plot mirrors the Spanish film Champions (and its Hollywood remake), with some accusing it of near “frame-by-frame” copying.
Prediction vs. Originality: While well-intended, some reviews described it as “well-meaning but simplistic,” calling out the lack of narrative innovation.
⭐ Ratings by Critics
A broad consensus among reviewers gives the film 3½ stars out of 5, including NDTV, Indian Express, Times of India, and Filmfare. Mixed voices emerged—Rediff rated it 2/5, calling it lacking dramatic impact , while Hollywood Reporter India felt it leaned too preachy.
Overall
Sitaare Zameen Par is a warm, inclusive drama with strong performances and wholesome messaging. Yet, its reliance on a proven template limits its originality. Fans of Aamir and emotionally driven cinema will appreciate it, but others may yearn for more creative risk-taking.
- Mumbai healthcare scam: Kapadia Hospital overcharges patient by a huge margin - September 5, 2025
- Bigg Boss fame Nyrraa M Banerji to speak on Indian Cinema at the Santiniketan Literature Festival; says ‘This is something very different for me’ - September 3, 2025
- Turning Waste into Wonder: Scientists Develop Biodegradable Plastic from Grapevines - September 2, 2025
- Shining in the Depths: The World’s Largest Glow-in-the-Dark Shark - September 1, 2025
- Branching into the Future: Indian Scientists Build Solar Trees - August 31, 2025
- Turning Air into Power: Berlin’s Bold Experiment with a Wind Chimney - August 29, 2025
- Storing the Sun: Engineers Build Sand Batteries in the Sahara Desert - August 28, 2025
- Whisper of the Future: France Debuts Blade-Free Wind Turbines - August 26, 2025
- One EV Equals Three Hybrids? Toyota’s Toyoda Ignites the Clean-Tech Debate - August 25, 2025
- Thirst from Thin Air: German Innovation Pulls Water from Airwave Sunlight Alone - August 22, 2025